Battle for New York? Last season both New York teams fell short of reaching the post-season, actually to put it plainly, they were mediocre at best. Sure there were bright spots, the rising star of Odell Beckham Jr. as a potential superstar in this league. And of course the New York Jets defensive stars: Muhammad Wilkerson & Sheldon Richardson proved they’ll be quite a duo for the next several years. But that isn’t what we are going to focus our attention on today, obviously. New York Jets fans know how bad Geno was last season & New York Giants fans know how inconsistent Eli was last season. But how bad were they really? How close were Geno’s & Eli’s stats, well let’s break it all down. Key statistic by key statistic, turnover by turnover, and ultimately who would you rather have Eli Manning or Geno Smith.